App Store Competition: How to Find Your Niche

Building an app is hard enough. Building an app that competes with Headspace, Calm, or Notion? That's basically impossible for an indie developer.

The good news: You don't have to.

Instead of fighting giants, you can find underserved niches where you're the only good option. Here's how.

The Indie Developer's Dilemma

You have an idea for a great app. You build it. You launch it. Then... nothing.

Why? Because you're competing in a saturated market against apps with:

• $100M+ in funding
• Teams of 50+ people
• Millions in ad spend
• Years of user reviews building trust

You can't win that fight. Not head-on.

The Niche Strategy

Instead of building "yet another meditation app", build:

• A meditation app specifically for people with ADHD
• A meditation app that integrates with Apple Watch
• A meditation app with sessions under 3 minutes

Same core functionality. Different target. Way less competition.

How to Identify a Good Niche

A profitable niche has three characteristics:

1. Specific Enough

"Fitness app" is not a niche. "Powerlifting workout tracker" is.

The narrower your focus, the easier it is to be the best option. You can't be the best fitness app. You CAN be the best powerlifting tracker.

2. Large Enough

"Workout tracker for left-handed people who only exercise on Tuesdays" is too specific. Nobody's searching for that.

Rule of thumb: Your niche should have at least 1,000 searches/month for related keywords. That's enough to build a sustainable app.

3. Underserved

Look for niches where:

• Top apps have ratings below 4.0 (users are frustrated)
• Top apps are general-purpose (opportunity for specialized tool)
• Top apps haven't been updated in 6+ months (developer abandoned it)

These are gap opportunities.

The Competitive Analysis Framework

Before you build, spend 2 hours doing this analysis. It'll save you months of wasted effort.

Step 1: Define Your Target Niche

Be specific:

• Who is it for? (e.g., "cyclists who train indoors")
• What problem does it solve? (e.g., "tracking intervals on a stationary bike")
• Why is it better? (e.g., "integrates with smart trainers")

Step 2: Search Relevant Keywords

Search 5-10 keywords related to your niche in the App Store:

• "cycling trainer app"
• "indoor cycling tracker"
• "smart trainer workout"
• "zwift alternative"
• etc.

Step 3: Analyze Top 10 Apps for Each Keyword

For each top-ranking app, document:

Quantitative:

• Rating (out of 5)
• Number of reviews
• Last update date
• Price/business model
• Ranking position

Qualitative:

• What features does it have?
• What's the main use case?
• What do recent reviews complain about?

Step 4: Identify Gaps

Look for patterns in the complaints:

• "Doesn't sync with my trainer" (integration gap)
• "Too complicated for beginners" (UX gap)
• "Missing feature X" (feature gap)
• "Crashes constantly" (quality gap)

These complaints are your opportunity.

Step 5: Calculate Competition Level

Score the niche from 1-10:

High competition (7-10):

• 10+ apps with 4.5+ stars
• Top apps have 100k+ reviews
• Market leaders (Zwift, Peloton, etc.)

Medium competition (4-6):

• Mix of strong and weak apps
• Some gaps in features
• Reviews show frustration

Low competition (1-3):

• No dominant player
• Apps have <4.0 stars
• Users actively complain about lack of options

Sweet spot: Medium competition (4-6). Low competition often means low demand.

Real Examples of Good Niches

Example 1: Task Manager for ADHD

Broad market: Todo apps (saturated - Todoist, Things, OmniFocus dominate)

Niche: Task management specifically for ADHD brains

Why it works:

• ADHD users have specific needs (time blindness, hyperfocus, etc.)
• General todo apps don't address these
• 4% of adults have ADHD = millions of potential users
• "ADHD task manager" has 2,500+ searches/month
• Top results are general todo apps (not specialized)

Competition level: 4/10 (medium-low)

Example 2: Fasting Tracker for Women

Broad market: Intermittent fasting apps (competitive - Zero, Fastic, etc.)

Niche: Fasting specifically designed around women's hormonal cycles

Why it works:

• Women need different fasting protocols than men
• Existing apps are gender-neutral (miss this nuance)
• "Fasting app for women" has 3,800+ searches/month
• Top apps don't specifically address hormonal cycles

Competition level: 5/10 (medium)

Example 3: Recipe Manager for Keto

Broad market: Recipe apps (very saturated)

Niche: Recipe manager with automatic macro tracking for keto diet

Why it works:

• Keto requires tracking macros (fat/protein/carbs)
• General recipe apps don't calculate these automatically
• "Keto recipe app" has 8,200+ searches/month
• Mix of weak and strong competitors

Competition level: 6/10 (medium)

The "But What If?" Concerns

"What if my niche is too small?"

If your target keywords have <500 searches/month combined, it's probably too small. But don't guess – validate with data.

"What if I build it and nobody cares?"

That's why you do this analysis BEFORE building. If there's search demand + gap in market, people care.

"What if a big player copies my idea?"

They won't. Big companies target big markets. Your niche is too small for them to notice. That's your moat.

"Can't I just build a general app and serve everyone?"

You could. You'll also get crushed by better-funded competitors. Specificity is your competitive advantage.

From Niche to Growth

Once you dominate a niche:

Phase 1: Own the niche

• Be the #1 app for your specific use case
• Get to 4.5+ stars with 1,000+ reviews
• Rank top 3 for your niche keywords

Phase 2: Expand adjacent niches

• Add features for related use cases
• Target slightly broader keywords
• Keep your core users happy

Phase 3: Become the category leader

• Now you have the reviews and rankings to compete broadly
• Gradually expand to general keywords
• You've earned the right to compete with the giants

Don't skip Phase 1. Most indie devs fail because they jump straight to Phase 3.

The Validation Checklist

Before you commit 3 months to building, validate:

• Primary keywords have 1,000+ combined searches/month
• Top 10 apps have identifiable gaps (features, UX, quality)
• Competition level is 6/10 or below
• You can articulate why your app is better for this specific niche
• The niche is growing or stable (not declining)
• You understand the target user's pain points
• There's a clear path to monetization

If you check all boxes, you've found a good niche.

Tools for Niche Research

Manual research (free but time-consuming):

1. Search App Store for relevant keywords
2. Read reviews of top apps
3. Join Reddit/Discord communities for your niche
4. Talk to potential users

Automated research (fast but costs money):

• asokai: Analyzes niches and shows opportunity scores
• App Store API: Raw data on rankings and reviews
• Google Trends: Validate demand over time

For indie devs on a budget: Start manual, use tools once you're generating revenue.

The Mindset Shift

Stop thinking: "How do I beat Headspace?"

Start thinking: "Who does Headspace ignore?"

Every big app has blind spots. Every broad market has underserved segments. Your job is finding them.

Action Plan

1. List 10 niche ideas related to your app concept
2. Research keywords for each (search volume + competition)
3. Analyze top 10 apps for your best 3 niches
4. Read 50+ reviews of competing apps (note complaints)
5. Pick the niche with best opportunity score
6. Build for that niche first

Then, and only then, start coding.

The Uncomfortable Truth

Most indie apps fail not because they're poorly built, but because they target impossible markets.

You have limited time, limited money, and limited attention. Don't waste it fighting battles you can't win.

Find your niche. Dominate it. Then expand.

That's how indie apps succeed in 2024.

---

Want to skip weeks of manual research? asokai analyzes competition and surfaces winning niches in under 60 seconds. Start now →